- News & Media
- Public & Community Health
- Apprenticeship Network Provider
AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION (WA)
It is well known that a doctor needs to have the informed consent of the patient (or their substitute decision-maker) before any treatment can be provided, except in emergencies.
The patient needs to be able to understand and remember the information they’ve been given about the treatment, demonstrate their understanding of the nature and effect of their decision, and communicate the decision in some way (in writing or orally).
Case Study 1
Helen, an emergency department nurse, was diagnosed with probable ovarian cancer. When imaging studies revealed a 17cm ovarian mass thought to be almost certainly malignant, she was scheduled for surgery. However, she cancelled at the last minute after a visit to a ‘healer/hypnotherapist’ recommended to her by a paramedic. The healer treated her with black salve. Helen died in April 2018 of ovarian cancer.
Case Study 2
Your patient, aged 92, declines investigation for chest pain. On discussing it with her, she explains that she feels she has had a full and complete life and doesn’t wish to undergo all the “prodding and poking” involved. She thanks you for your careful explanations and all the options you’ve outlined, but says she doesn’t want to be referred. True to her word, the patient doesn’t seek any further treatment. Several months later, she suffers a myocardial infarction and dies at home.
What if your patient refuses recommended treatment?
A patient with capacity can decline treatment. Capacity is the ability to make and understand information relevant to a decision, and the ability to appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of a decision (or lack of a decision).
Adults are assumed to have capacity. They are free to make their own choices regarding treatment. If a patient declines recommended treatment, it doesn’t follow that they lack capacity. However, the decision must be given voluntarily. This means the decision must be made freely and not under undue pressure, coercion or manipulation.
A decision to decline treatment for a child is more complex. Parents generally make decisions for children who are not mature minors. Parental power should be exercised in the best interests of the child and is not unlimited. It’s advisable to obtain legal advice in relation to such matters.
This article is provided by MDA National. They recommend that you contact your indemnity provider if you need specific advice in relation to your insurance policy.